Torture

7. Torture

definition

  • inflicting real or perceived pain and punishment on a person to create fear
  • Information is easily extracted from people who are fearful
  • the victim conducts a cost benefit analysis of giving information versus experiencing future punishment
  • during torture fear is primary and pain is secondary
  • ticking time bomb scenario: fear must be created quickly to extract information before a deadline

effectiveness

  • if torture wasn't effective then we wouldn't be having this debate so assume that it works
  • you are 1/3 more likely to support torture if a terrorist attack has occurred and vice versa
  • ethics of responsibility - Weber

reliable information

  • humans lie all the time
  • people are even more likely to lie during coercive interrogation,
  • people are not more likely to lie when being tortured than when experiencing coercive interrogation
  • the solution to dealing with lies is corroboration

morality

  • a political agenda presupposes a moral agenda
  • both sides want to champion a higher cause
  • torture destroy's the morale of soldiers
  • the solution to keeping morale high is to torture in secret and have veterens perform the torturing.
Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License